top of page
Search

Why AI Can't Steal My Mic: The Irreplaceable Publicist

  • Jerome Cleary
  • Oct 29
  • 3 min read

As a publicist, my years of pitching stories and crafting press releases cannot be replaced by AI.
As a publicist, my years of pitching stories and crafting press releases cannot be replaced by AI.

There's a lot of noise out there about Artificial Intelligence (AI) coming for every job, and yes, that includes public relations. You see the headlines: "AI-Powered Press Releases," "Automated Media List Building," "Robots Doing Your PR."

Sure, AI is a powerful tool—I use it myself for things like data analysis and speeding up routine tasks. But let's be absolutely clear: AI will never truly replace a talented publicist. Why? Because the heart of public relations isn't about data processing; it's about human connection, nuanced storytelling, and irreplaceable strategic instinct.

The Instinct: Strategy Over Algorithm

AI excels at recognizing patterns and optimizing processes. It can tell you who wrote about a topic, but it can't tell you why that specific journalist is the perfect match for your wildly unconventional client launch next quarter.

My value, and the value of any seasoned publicist, is in the strategic instinct that no algorithm can replicate:

  • The Gut Feeling: Knowing, often before the data confirms it, which pitch will resonate and which will land in the spam folder.

  • Reading the Room (or the Newsroom): Understanding the subtle shifts in the media landscape, the politics of a publication, or the current mood of the culture—and pivoting the strategy instantly.

  • Crisis Empathy: When a crisis hits, an AI can draft a statement based on templates, but it can't feel the public's anger, gauge the CEO's anxiety, or inject the necessary authenticity and remorse into a delicate communication. Empathy is a human-only skill.

The Art of Persuasion and Relationship Building

PR is a business of relationships. While an AI can scan millions of profiles and find a reporter's email, it can’t build the trust and rapport that leads to genuine, quality coverage.

My irreplaceable skills live in the handshake, the coffee chat, and the perfectly timed follow-up:

  • The Human Pitch: A perfect pitch isn't just well-written; it’s personal. It acknowledges the reporter's recent work, offers a unique angle they haven't covered, and demonstrates respect for their time and beat. This level of nuanced, personalized persuasion requires human judgment and years of relationship capital.

  • The Connector: I don't just connect a client to a reporter; I connect their story to the reporter's audience in a meaningful way. I act as a cultural translator, ensuring the message resonates with the human experience.

  • Negotiating Nuance: When working with a journalist on a sensitive or exclusive story, the back-and-forth negotiation—managing expectations, clarifying facts, and ensuring the brand’s voice is heard accurately—is a delicate dance that requires emotional intelligence and diplomatic finesse.

✨ The One-of-a-Kind Talent: Creative Storytelling

AI can assemble words into sentences. I, and publicists like me, craft narratives that move people.

My true value lies in turning a dry product launch or a complicated B-to-B white paper into an irresistible, newsworthy story. This is pure, unadulterated creativity:

  • Finding the Magic: I dig deep into a client's history, mission, and people to find the human element—the anecdote, the moment, the motivation—that will capture the imagination of millions.

  • Cultural Relevance: I possess the cultural intelligence to spot a trend before it peaks, to know which stories will go viral versus which will just sit flat. This requires being a student of culture, psychology, and the constant, messy flow of human interest.

The Future is Augmentation, Not Replacement

The publicist of the future is someone who wields AI as a mighty sidekick, not a competitor.

I'll let the bots handle the rote tasks: scraping data, scheduling posts, and drafting first-pass copy. But the strategy, the creative spark, the relationship management, and the crisis judgment? Those are mine. They are the one-of-a-kind skills and talent I’ve honed over years—the very things that make a public relations victory truly impactful.

So, while AI is busy automating the mundane, I’ll be busy doing what I do best: building the relationships and crafting the stories that truly change perceptions.

Comments


bottom of page